Skip to content
Branding

Court orders Instagram and Facebook to offer an algorithm-free option

Tired of the Instagram and Facebook algorithms deciding what you see? There is good news.

Lotte Seinen

Marketing Lead

2 min read3 chapters
Share

Tired of the Instagram and Facebook algorithms deciding what you see? There is good news. The court in Amsterdam has ruled that Meta must offer an algorithm-free option in the Netherlands for both Instagram and Facebook.

This means you will soon be able to choose a chronological news feed yourself, without interference from algorithms that think they know your interests.

The ruling follows a lawsuit brought by Bits of Freedom and promises more control over your online experience.

Read on to find out exactly what this means for you and what steps Meta now has to take.

The landmark ruling

The Amsterdam court has issued a ruling that has caused quite a stir: Meta must give users in the Netherlands the option to make their Instagram and Facebook feeds algorithm-free.

In practice this means you can set a chronological timeline as your default view, a direct result of a lawsuit brought by the civil rights organisation Bits of Freedom.

What does this mean for you in concrete terms? You get the freedom to choose a feed that is not personalised by algorithms analysing your presumed preferences.

Although a similar option already exists, it is currently hard to find and cannot be chosen as a permanent setting. That is about to change.

Bits of Freedom brought the case on the grounds that the current practices of Instagram and Facebook are in breach of the European Digital Services Act.

The court has upheld that position, ruling in the organisation's favour.

Deadline

Meta now faces a tight deadline: the apps must be adapted for Dutch users within two weeks. If Meta misses that deadline, a substantial penalty of 100,000 euros per day becomes payable to Bits of Freedom, up to a maximum of five million euros. The pressure is well and truly on.
"Fantastic, a real boost for everyone trying to rein in Meta's power,"
said Evelyn Austin, director of Bits of Freedom. Her words underline the significance of the ruling for digital civil rights.

Wider impact and Meta's response

The lawsuit was originally brought with the upcoming elections in mind, amid fears that algorithmically selected content could influence votes. The judge, however, decided that the change remains in force after the elections of 29 October as well, a point Meta strongly contested.

Although this specific ruling applies only to the Netherlands, Austin points to a broader context:

"That is the scope of this court. But the European law at issue here applies throughout Europe,"
This suggests that similar developments are possible in other European countries.

Meta has already announced that it will appeal the judgment. The company "fundamentally disagrees" and argues that this is a matter for the European Commission, not for individual courts in EU member states.

The Amsterdam court's ruling marks an important step in the debate about algorithms and online privacy. It gives users more control over their feeds and puts pressure on Meta to be more transparent.

We will keep you informed of further developments in this high-profile case.

The landmark ruling

The Amsterdam court has issued a ruling that has caused quite a stir: Meta must give users in the Netherlands the option to make their Instagram and Facebook feeds algorithm-free.

In practice this means you can set a chronological timeline as your default view, a direct result of a lawsuit brought by the civil rights organisation Bits of Freedom.

What does this mean for you in concrete terms? You get the freedom to choose a feed that is not personalised by algorithms analysing your presumed preferences.

Although a similar option already exists, it is currently hard to find and cannot be chosen as a permanent setting. That is about to change.

 

Bits of Freedom brought the case on the grounds that the current practices of Instagram and Facebook are in breach of the European Digital Services Act.

 

The court has upheld that position, ruling in the organisation's favour.

Deadline

Meta now faces a tight deadline: the apps must be adapted for Dutch users within two weeks. If Meta misses that deadline, a substantial penalty of 100,000 euros per day becomes payable to Bits of Freedom, up to a maximum of five million euros. The pressure is well and truly on.

"Fantastic, a real boost for everyone trying to rein in Meta's power,"
said Evelyn Austin, director of Bits of Freedom. Her words underline the significance of the ruling for digital civil rights.

Wider impact and Meta's response

The lawsuit was originally brought with the upcoming elections in mind, amid fears that algorithmically selected content could influence votes. The judge, however, decided that the change remains in force after the elections of 29 October as well, a point Meta strongly contested.

 

Although this specific ruling applies only to the Netherlands, Austin points to a broader context:

"That is the scope of this court. But the European law at issue here applies throughout Europe,"

 

This suggests that similar developments are possible in other European countries.

Meta has already announced that it will appeal the judgment. The company "fundamentally disagrees" and argues that this is a matter for the European Commission, not for individual courts in EU member states.

 

 

The Amsterdam court's ruling marks an important step in the debate about algorithms and online privacy. It gives users more control over their feeds and puts pressure on Meta to be more transparent.

We will keep you informed of further developments in this high-profile case.

What next?

Share

Further reading

Branding5 January 20243 min

The 12 brand archetypes of Jung

You may have heard of them, you may not. When you build a brand, you always go back to the core.

Branding5 January 20243 min

The neuroscience behind branding

Throughout the day, your brain is constantly processing stimuli and actively remembering or forgetting information.

Want to talk it through?

Reading is one thing. Knowing what it means for you is another.

Half an hour, online or at our office in Ede or Amsterdam. No pitch, no obligations. An honest answer within two days, including when that answer is that you do not need us.

Niels Teunissen

Niels Teunissen

Oprichter

Replies within a day

Free check·30 sec

How visible is your website?

Over twenty checks on SEO, technology and whether an AI model can quote you.